Kurt Russell Sheriff Franklin Hunt Patrick Wilson Arthur O'Dwyer Richard Jenkins Chicory Matthew Fox John Brooder Lili Simmons Samantha O'Dwyer David Arquette Purvis Fred Melamed Clarence Evan Jonigkeit Nick Sid Haig Buddy Maestro Harrell Gizzard James Tolkan Pianist Kathryn Morris Lorna Hunt Zahn McClarnon The Professor Michael Emery Redheaded Fellow Jeremy Tardy Buford Michael Paré Mr. Wallington Sean Young Mrs. Porter Jamison Newlander The Mayor Erick Chavarria Ramiro Omar Leyva Guapo David Midthunder Misshapen Troglodyte (uncredited) Geno Segers Boar Tusks Alex Meraz Eagle Skulls Robert Allen Mukes Sentinel Brandon Molale Noseless Troglodyte (uncredited) Eddie Spears Serrated Tomahawk Jay Tavare Sharp Teeth Mario Pérez Mexican Man Kurt Russell Sheriff Franklin Hunt Patrick Wilson Arthur O'Dwyer Richard Jenkins Chicory Matthew Fox John Brooder Lili Simmons Samantha O'Dwyer David Arquette Purvis Fred Melamed Clarence Evan Jonigkeit Nick Sid Haig Buddy Maestro Harrell Gizzard James Tolkan Pianist Kathryn Morris Lorna Hunt Zahn McClarnon The Professor Michael Emery Redheaded Fellow Jeremy Tardy Buford Michael Paré Mr. Wallington Sean Young Mrs. Porter Jamison Newlander The Mayor Erick Chavarria Ramiro Omar Leyva Guapo David Midthunder Misshapen Troglodyte (uncredited) Geno Segers Boar Tusks Alex Meraz Eagle Skulls Robert Allen Mukes Sentinel Brandon Molale Noseless Troglodyte (uncredited) Eddie Spears Serrated Tomahawk Jay Tavare Sharp Teeth Mario Pérez Mexican Man