Rainn Wilson Frank Darbo Elliot Page Libby Liv Tyler Sarah Kevin Bacon Jacques Gregg Henry Detective John Felkner Michael Rooker Abe Andre Royo Hamilton Sean Gunn Toby Stephen Blackehart Quill Linda Cardellini Pet Store Employee Nathan Fillion The Holy Avenger Gerardo Davila Cop Paul T. Taylor Frank Sr. Connor Day Teenage Frank James Gunn Demonswill Mikaela Hoover Holly Nick Holmes Jim Rob Zombie Voice Of God Steve Agee Comic Book Store Jerk Laurel Whitsett Librarian James Lentzsch Passenger Teen Nate Rubin Driving Teen Danny Cosmo Purse-snatcher Russell Towery Chickenhawk Mollie Milligan Sarah's Sister Gerry May Newscaster Valentine Miele Line Butter Darcel White Moreno Waitress Lindsey Soileau Libby's Friend Brandon Belknap Christian Zach Gilford Jerry Lloyd Kaufman 911 Man Mark De Alessandro Thug Jumped On By Boltie Cole S. McKay Thug Set On Fire Dominick LaBanca Thug #1 Rainn Wilson Frank Darbo Elliot Page Libby Liv Tyler Sarah Kevin Bacon Jacques Gregg Henry Detective John Felkner Michael Rooker Abe Andre Royo Hamilton Sean Gunn Toby Stephen Blackehart Quill Linda Cardellini Pet Store Employee Nathan Fillion The Holy Avenger Gerardo Davila Cop Paul T. Taylor Frank Sr. Connor Day Teenage Frank James Gunn Demonswill Mikaela Hoover Holly Nick Holmes Jim Rob Zombie Voice Of God Steve Agee Comic Book Store Jerk Laurel Whitsett Librarian James Lentzsch Passenger Teen Nate Rubin Driving Teen Danny Cosmo Purse-snatcher Russell Towery Chickenhawk Mollie Milligan Sarah's Sister Gerry May Newscaster Valentine Miele Line Butter Darcel White Moreno Waitress Lindsey Soileau Libby's Friend Brandon Belknap Christian Zach Gilford Jerry Lloyd Kaufman 911 Man Mark De Alessandro Thug Jumped On By Boltie Cole S. McKay Thug Set On Fire Dominick LaBanca Thug #1 John W. Lawson Thug Missing Arms William Katt Sgt. Fitzgibbon Christine Bently Stoner Girl Rainn Wilson Frank Darbo Elliot Page Libby Liv Tyler Sarah Kevin Bacon Jacques Gregg Henry Detective John Felkner Michael Rooker Abe Andre Royo Hamilton Sean Gunn Toby Stephen Blackehart Quill Linda Cardellini Pet Store Employee Nathan Fillion The Holy Avenger Gerardo Davila Cop Paul T. Taylor Frank Sr. Connor Day Teenage Frank James Gunn Demonswill Mikaela Hoover Holly Nick Holmes Jim Rob Zombie Voice Of God Steve Agee Comic Book Store Jerk Laurel Whitsett Librarian James Lentzsch Passenger Teen Nate Rubin Driving Teen Danny Cosmo Purse-snatcher Russell Towery Chickenhawk Mollie Milligan Sarah's Sister Gerry May Newscaster Valentine Miele Line Butter Darcel White Moreno Waitress Lindsey Soileau Libby's Friend Brandon Belknap Christian Zach Gilford Jerry Lloyd Kaufman 911 Man Mark De Alessandro Thug Jumped On By Boltie Cole S. McKay Thug Set On Fire Dominick LaBanca Thug #1 John W. Lawson Thug Missing Arms William Katt Sgt. Fitzgibbon Christine Bently Stoner Girl