Billy Eichner Bobby Leiber Luke Macfarlane Aaron Guy Branum Henry Miss Lawrence Wanda Ts Madison Angela Dot-Marie Jones Cherry Jim Rash Robert Eve Lindley Tamara Monica Raymund Tina Guillermo Díaz Edgar Jai Rodriguez Jason Amanda Bearse Anne Debra Messing Debra Messing Peter Y. Kim Peter Symone Marty Ryan Faucett Josh Evans Bowen Yang Lawrence Grape Harvey Fierstein Lewis Brock Ciarlelli Steve Kristin Chenoweth Kristin Chenoweth Matthew Wilkas Handsome Grindr Guy George Dvorsky Bruce Ben Stiller Ben Stiller (uncredited) Kenan Thompson James Baldwin Amy Schumer Eleanor Roosevelt Seth Meyers Harvey Milk (uncredited) Rick Crom Grape's Neighbor Anthony DeVito Liberal Dad Benito Skinner Billy Eichner Bobby Leiber Luke Macfarlane Aaron Guy Branum Henry Miss Lawrence Wanda Ts Madison Angela Dot-Marie Jones Cherry Jim Rash Robert Eve Lindley Tamara Monica Raymund Tina Guillermo Díaz Edgar Jai Rodriguez Jason Amanda Bearse Anne Debra Messing Debra Messing Peter Y. Kim Peter Symone Marty Ryan Faucett Josh Evans Bowen Yang Lawrence Grape Harvey Fierstein Lewis Brock Ciarlelli Steve Kristin Chenoweth Kristin Chenoweth Matthew Wilkas Handsome Grindr Guy George Dvorsky Bruce Ben Stiller Ben Stiller (uncredited) Kenan Thompson James Baldwin Amy Schumer Eleanor Roosevelt Seth Meyers Harvey Milk (uncredited) Rick Crom Grape's Neighbor Anthony DeVito Liberal Dad Benito Skinner