Daniel Kaluuya OJ Haywood Keke Palmer Emerald 'Em' Haywood Steven Yeun Ricky 'Jupe' Park Brandon Perea Angel Torres Michael Wincott Antlers Holst Wrenn Schmidt Amber Park Keith David Otis Haywood Sr. Terry Notary Gordy Devon Graye Ryder Muybridge Barbie Ferreira Nessie Donna Mills Bonnie Clayton Oz Perkins Fynn Bachman Eddie Jemison Buster Sophia Coto Mary Jo Elliot Jennifer Lafleur Phyllis Mayberry / Margaret Houston Andrew Patrick Ralston Tom Bogan / Brett Houston Lincoln Lambert Kolton Park Pierce Kang Phoenix Park Ryan W. Garcia Officer Reyes Conor Kawalski Parker Alex Hyde-White Grizz Evan Shafran Studio Security Guard Liza Treyger Commercial Makeup Artist