Andrew Garfield Jonathan Larson Alexandra Shipp Susan Robin de Jesús Michael Vanessa Hudgens Karessa Johnson Joshua Henry Roger Bradley Whitford Stephen Sondheim Black Thought H.A.W.K. Smooth Joel Grey Allan Larson Lin-Manuel Miranda Diner Manager Phillipa Soo Lady at Diner 1 Renée Elise Goldsberry Lady at Diner 2 Daphne Rubin-Vega Lady at Diner 3 MJ Rodriguez Carolyn Richard Kind Walter Bloom Judith Light Rosa Stevens Joanna Adler Molly Noah Robbins Simon Kenita R. Miller Sextet Actor #2 Ken Holmes YMCA Poolgoer (uncredited) Laura Benanti Judy Danielle Ferland Kim Micaela Diamond Peggy Utkarsh Ambudkar Todd Gizel Jimenez Cristin Kate Rockwell Lauren Judy Kuhn Nan Danny Burstein Al Ryan Vasquez Scott