Nina Dobrev Elizabeth Daniels Vanessa Hudgens Tara Adam Pally Dax Eva Longoria Grace Chapman Rob Corddry Kurt Chapman Tone Bell Jimmy Johnston Jon Bass Garrett Michael Cassidy Dr. Mike Stone Finn Wolfhard Tyler Ron Cephas Jones Walter Thomas Lennon Greg Tig Notaro Danielle Thornhill Lauren Lapkus Daisy Jessica St. Clair Ruth Ryan Hansen Peter Tony Cavalero Stanley Jessica Lowe Amy Mo Gaffney Mayor Velez Jasmine Cephas Jones Lola Casey Deidrick Jude Phoebe Neidhardt Alexa John Gemberling Ernie Arielle Vandenberg Kristen Toks Olagundoye Nina Ken Marino Carven Wagi David Wain Wacky Wayne Megan Park Kelli Gina Ward Addie Joseph Bezenek Baby Shower Husband (uncredited)