Tim Matheson Ronald Reagan Cynthia Nixon Nancy Reagan Kyle S. More John Hinckley Jr Mike Pniewski Jack Hinckley Joel Murray Edwin Meese Patrick St. Esprit Alexander Haig Joe Chrest Jerry Parr Gary Weeks Stephen Colo Leander Suleiman Dr. Joyce Mitchell Geoff Pierson James Baker Brian F. Durkin Detective Eddie Myers James Martin Kelly Don Regan Jim Dougherty Judge William Higgins Dane Rhodes Richard Allen Kendrick Cross Danny Spriggs Ashley LeConte Campbell Jim Baker's Secretary Trey McGriff David C Fischer Michael H. Cole Jim Brady Tom Hillmann Dr Joseph Giordano Chris Hlozek Robert Wanko Dustin Lewis Ted Graber Amber Erwin Katie Kay Galvin Margaret Thatcher Annie Humphrey Sarah Brady Dave MacDonald Tim McCarthy