Judy Greer Shannon Aubrey Plaza Kelly Natasha Lyonne Martha Clea DuVall Regina Ron Livingston Edwin Allison Tolman Ruby Molly Shannon Margaret Lipka Fred Armisen Gerald Jessica St. Clair Kristen Malcolm Barrett Eric Edward Barbanell Jerry Davenia McFadden Denise Jon Daly Boris Lipka Paul Bates Henry Michael Hitchcock David Beth Grant Tilda Dave Silva Motel Clerk Kumail Nanjiani Damon Maria Olsen Softball Player (uncredited)