David Howard Thornton Steamboat Willie Jesse Kove Lieutenant Diaz Jesse Posey Pete Charles Edwin Powell Borough President Molinari Amy Schumacher Amber Jarlath Conroy Barry Allison Pittel Selena Jarod Lindsey Moses Rumi C. Jean-Louis Matteo Anthony E. Williams Officer Martinez Tyler Posey Radio Operator Mike Jared Johnston Neil Brian Quinn Mitch McEverly Kailey Hyman Cindi Brian Scolaro Captain Clark Sarah Kopkin Ilsa Arindel Tommy Bechtold TJ Joe DeRosa Paul Sanguino Ken Maharaj Albert Michael Leavy Deckhand Bert Brunswick Poonam Basu Jazzy Steven Della Salla Charlie DeLorenzo Jason Lockhart Cyclist Peter Allyson Sereboff Aubrey Rachel Victoria Moore Jamie Gilbrando Acevedo The Shirtless Cowboy Buzz Roddy Officer Pat O'Hare Peter Romano Officer Chris Tammi Cubilette Liz