Amanda Seyfried Sophie Christopher Egan Charlie Gael García Bernal Victor Vanessa Redgrave Claire Franco Nero Lorenzo Luisa Ranieri Isabella Milena Vukotić Maria Marina Massironi Francesca Marcia DeBonis Lorraine Luisa De Santis Angelina Lidia Biondi Donatella Remo Remotti Farm House Lorenzo Ivana Lotito Young Girl Angelo Infanti Chess Playing Lorenzo Giacomo Piperno Lorenzo on Lake Fabio Testi Count Lorenzo Silvana Bosi Take Him Lorenzo's Wife Elio Veller Grocer Lorenzo Sandro Dori Priest Lorenzo Daniel Emilio Baldock Lorenzo - Father Ashley Lilley Patricia Peter Arpesella American Tourist (voice) (uncredited) Laura Jane Jones Singer - soloist (uncredited) Oliver Platt New Yorker Magazine Editor Bobby (uncredited) Uzimann Hot Dog Vendor (uncredited)