Ayo Edebiri Ariel John Malkovich Moretti Juliette Lewis Clara Armstrong Murray Bartlett Stan Stephanie Suganami Emily Young Mazino Kent Amber Midthunder Belle Tony Hale Soledad Yusef Tatanka Means Najee Peter Diseth Jorg Melissa Chambers Bianca Tyson Mark Sivertsen Bill Lotto Aspen Martinez Maude Jasper Keen Lee Sarah May Sommers Karaoke Singer Aimee McGuire Editor #2 Orion Carrington Journalist Chris Highlands Editor #3 Jean Effron Receptionist Gabriel Armijo Fraternity Member Casey Messer GDA Host Rosario Dawson Billie Holiday Bill Burr Bill Burr Lenny Kravitz Moretti Superfan #1 Lil Nas X Moretti Superfan #2 Crystal Mayes Mother Levelist (uncredited)