John Lloyd Young Francis 'Frankie Valli' Castelluccio Vincent Piazza Gaetano 'Tommy' DeVito Michael Lomenda Nick Massi Erich Bergen Bob Gaudio Christopher Walken Angelo 'Gyp' DeCarlo Mike Doyle Bob Crewe Joseph Russo Joe 'Joey' Pesci Kathrine Narducci Mary Rinaldi Freya Tingley Francine Valli Johnny Cannizzaro Nick DeVito James Madio Stosh Francesca Eastwood Waitress Steve Schirripa Vito Barry Livingston Accountant Alexis Krause Party Girl Jeremy Luke Donnie Silvia Kal Producer's Wife Billy Gardell Our Sons Owner John Griffin Billy Dixon Elizabeth Hunter Francine (age 7) Lacey Hannan Angela Erica Piccininni Lorraine Steve Monroe Barry Belson Grant Roberts Johnny Sean Whalen Engneer Kara Pacitto Bubble-Head #2 Michael Patrick McGill Officer Mike Nancy La Scala Art Loving Woman Clint Ward Officer Stanley Jackie Seiden Angel #2 Matt Nolan Engineer #2 Meagan Holder Jazz Singer Joe Abraham Rockabilly Singer Phil Abrams Publisher #3 Joe Howard Priest Bill Watterson Backup Musician #2 Annika Noelle Nick's Date Kimmy Gatewood Angel #1 Alexandra Ruddy Waitress Keith Loneker Knuckles Aria Pullman Attractive Woman Annie O'Donnell Nun John Duerler Bartender Louis Lombardi Trulio James P. Bennett Stage Hand (uncredited)