Maika Monroe Jay Height Keir Gilchrist Paul Daniel Zovatto Greg Hannigan Jake Weary Hugh Olivia Luccardi Yara Lili Sepe Kelly Height Bailey Spry Annie Carollette Phillips Woman with Groceries Ruby Harris Mrs. Redmond Leisa Pulido Mrs. Hannigan Linda Boston Teacher Kourtney Bell Chatting Girl Claire Sloma Greg's Date (Pretty Girl in Car) Scott Norman Homeless Man Behind Tree Ele Bardha Mr. Height Rich Vreeland High School Announcer (uncredited)