Ilana Glazer Eden Michelle Buteau Dawn John Carroll Lynch Dr. Morris Oliver Platt Bernie Sandra Bernhard Dr. Shirley Stephan James Claude Hasan Minhaj Marty Keith Lucas Bobby Kenneth Lucas Benny Mario Polit EMT Donna Glaesener Delivery Nurse Katy Grenfell Postpartum Nurse 1 Rosa Gilmore Lactation Leslie Whoopi Goldberg Dawn's Breasts Nic Inglese Bou Jarmas (Ticket Salesperson) Shola Adewusi Nanny Dani Susanna Guzman Nanny Ramona Holly Chou Carla Simone Recasner Paula (Doula 1) Darren Criss Doula as a Man Tony Ray Rossi Plumber Paul Borghese Other Actor